Who has read this book and how was it good or bad? And please dont tell me specifics about the book as im only on chapter 5. im warning u and ill report any1 who tells me anything bout the book other than if it was good or bad, im serious cause i want 2 find out the story myself

i just finished it yesterday.
i liked it.but i feel sad that the books end.
there r twist n turns as u can expected from HP books.

if the movie version of this book comes out , it would be an epic! yeah!

Gosh, it's only a book. I have read it and it's very good. I love it. I felt like it gave me the answers to the last six books. But of course it should as it the last book.....So now I'm going to read the Harry Potter books all over again.
And why do you want to know if it's good or bad? If you don't want people to ruin it for you then why'd you ask?

This post has been edited by -x-Jen-x-: Jul 31 2007, 10:19 AM

Yeah it was good but theres still one question I need to know so whoever hasnt read it dont read any more....



spoiler!!!!!!











ok well In chapter titled "the deathly hallows" harry claims he heard marvolo gaunt(voldemort's grandad) say his ring once belonged to the peverells, that he was their descendant or something like that I forget. Well it's revelaed the cloak was passed down from generation to generation and finally it landed in harry's hands sooooo wouldnt that make voldemort and harry related?? any thoughts?

All pure-blood families are inter-related in one way or another. So they would. I've look up the Tree of Harry Potter and that 'coz of a school computer class project. So in one way or another they are.

From the start the book was already vary dark...there's lot of twists and surprises, that really makes you head spin and you hold your breath almost at every scene....

This book is in my opinion the 2nd best in the series (half-blood prince being my personal favourite) however this book is good cause it ties off all the lose ends. taking that into consideration i kinda felt that she only made up the deathly hallows as she was writing this book and didnt have it planned all along did anyone else feel like this after the book?

i finally finished it, i think Rowling could have done better with the book, but only part i was disappointed in was when theyre grown up and harry and ginny marry and all that suff, she didnt give much info so i think she couldve done that better